The Cody Word
  • June 16, 2009 11:15 AM EDT by Cody Willard

    I was wrong: Gold's going to crash

    The government’s been bailing out entire industries left and right. The Fed’s got their Fed Fund rates at 0%, giving banks the ability to borrow taxpayer money at no cost in this country. The Fed’s guaranteed trillions in worthless debt at the world’s biggest investment banks. You’d think the money supply in this country would be exploding right now. Certainly, that’s what I’d been expecting to see as the overpowering macroeconomic trend in this country for the next two to five years.

    Alas the money supply, especially if you reconstruct the M3 money supply which the government used to publish as the most complete measure of how much liquid money is sloshing around this country, is collapsing. It stood to reason that if the Fed and Treasury are willing to print worthless dollars to send to the corrupt and insolvent banks, that a bunch of those worthless dollars would gush their way into the economy and increase the money supply. That increased money supply would devalue the existing money supply. That devaluation of the dollar would then likely translate into a bull market for gold.

    But something happened on the way from the pump. See, all those same insolvent banks don’t just have all those trillions of worthless debt that they’ve stupidly risked their depositors’ savings on. No, those same banks decided to take their customer’s monies and risk them in secondary, derivative markets that were initially created to “insure” all those trillions in worthless loans the stupid banks made. Like a poker player on a losing streak, they started betting ten times as much on the derivative markets as they had in the actual lending markets. You know who they thought would pay them and make those insurance payments if those bets were to work out? Mostly AIG. And other insolvent banks.

    They did this ten times over, dwarfing their initial bets that they’d already made ten times over on their depositors’ money, eventually gambling on tens of trillions of dollars on insurance on that worthless debt.

    And now that the cows have come home and real estate et al is collapsing in this country, these same insolvent banks have to make their balance sheets look better even as they have tens of trillions of dollars of losses that they’re pretending don’t exist.  That's because even after the government has made these corrupt banks whole on about $200 billion of worthless insurance they bought from AIG, $200 billion is a small fraction of what the banks have actually pretended they’ve got on their balance sheets and that they’ve now got to “mark to market” slowly but surely.

    And as those trillions of dollars of losses are brought back onto their balance sheets and recognized for the reality they are, the banks find themselves ever more insolvent. And so they have to hoard every dollar they can get their hands on to try to build up their reserves. And that means that despite all that taxpayer money being given hand over fist to these insolvent banks that the money supply keeps shrinking. In the US economy, debt creation equaled money creation which meant the money supply was increasing. Debt is being destroyed now and that means money is being destroyed. And that means money supply is decreasing.

    And this trend isn’t about to reverse itself magically. The money will keep being sopped up by these insolvent banks’ balance sheets until they are forced to recapitalize entirely – washing their shareholders who foolishly bet on bad management (and often dishonest, fraudulent management such as at Bank of America and Goldman Sachs where the executives in charge always deny their need for capital even when they are desperate for capital), hurting the people who risked their money lending the company money (bondholders, that is) and ensuring that every depositor is made whole.

    The preceding sentence is what the government is supposed to do now since Timothy Geithner, Mary Shapiro, Sheila Bair and the rest of the bureaucrats at the SEC and the FED and the FDIC completely failed at their jobs of protecting depositors’ money and policing for ponzi schemes and making sure the banks didn’t lever themselves up recklessly.

    Until the FDIC, the FED and the SEC start doing their job and while they continue to redistribute trillions of working people’s money to the shareholders and counterparties of these corrupt, insolvent banks, we’re going to see wealth in this country destroyed and the money supply decline.

    And that’s why gold ain’t going higher any longer. Gold can be a great hedge when the money supply is exploding. I’m still convinced that we’ll see inflation in many commodities that we “need”, such as food and milk. But betting on gold to go higher in a situation where dollars are actually being eaten out of the system isn’t the bet I want to make. Indeed, because of this new analysis, I expect we’ll see gold below $500 an ounce sometime in the next year or two.

    Best bet for the next two to five years – higher interest rates. Regardless of where the FED keeps its FED Funds Rate (they can keep it at 0% forever if they want) the cost of capital in this country and around the world is going higher. The money supply is dropping and people are going to want more interest on the money they lend the US government, the private sector and anybody else. I’m open to ideas on what the best strategy for betting on higher market rates over the next two to five years is. Anybody out there think they got the best play on higher rates?

zircon

I hope we do not return to the inflation of the late 70's and early 80's. The only good thing about those times, CD rates were well above 10% for a 10K CD. If you had the cash you did ok in that market. I think if you want property as a hedge its a 15 year return. All of the 60's gneration can't afford to buy now. The 30's generation is just starting and they will not buy either. We are in a very bad long bottom. Worst I have seen since 1958/9 recession. I say don't invest yet,the bottom may still be punching through and you may not have the guts to ride it out. Horde your cash, buy only necessities, pay down debt, live cheap, and get a cheaper mortgage if you don't mind a couple of points and 4-5k in closing cost[ I don't suggest that but rather double up on payments instead or pay more principle than required]. Why pay a bank to refinance its nuts. That makes sense if you have a 6-7% mortgage. Too me its hunker down, fix the 4-5 year old car, delay the vacation this year, do not buy the new carpet. Anything to hold onto your money. Life is still good if you have a job. Zircon

June 16, 2009 at 1:47 pm

Atlanta movers

I to think interest rates are headed higher not so much due to broad based inflation (I don't see the prices off all things headed higher quickly) more so of targeted inflation where things tied to the strength of the dollar as a function of the world wanting more and more interest to keep lending us/the government the huge amounts of money we will need to borrow. At the same time I think "assets" like homes and land will continue to deflate. The increase in rates will be tied more to the dept level growth of our government and cost of oil/gas (which will increase in costs as the value of the dollar decreases and money sitting on the side lines looks for something to invest in) than the increase in the number of dollars (as you stated many of the dollars printed are not making it into the "real economy")

June 16, 2009 at 1:44 pm

BJ Miller

"Until the FDIC, the FED and the SEC start doing their job....we’re going to see wealth in this country destroyed and the money supply decline." That statement argues against a gold crash. Who in their right mind would sit back and let wealth be destroyed. Long before we completely destroy wealth in this country, 'average Joe' will figure out it is better to buy a $20 bag of rice at Sam's Club instead of leaving it in the financial system. The dollar has been sinking since 2000 and has only gained strength due to the unwinding of Wall St. and a flight to safety. For gold to crash, the dollar would have to gain a tremendous amount of strength - how will that happen?

June 16, 2009 at 1:35 pm

Dojax

Cody, you must know much more about this than I. But is it a safe idea to start moving money out of US dollars into a country that isn't destroying it's currency and has something to back up its money supply besides hope, change and lies? I don't know what countries would be considered safe monetary investments. I've heard the Canada or Australian dollar should be much safer. Would that be a good move or not? Or won't it make much difference for the coming problems? I'd like to save the money I was able to salvage out of my 401ks before the rest of it gets inflated away. Or the 3 Ring Freak Show in Washington finds new and better ways to steal it.

June 16, 2009 at 1:17 pm

MAX

Much like the FDR years, the nation will have at least seven years of famine. It's essential to keep some cash stash (in spite of the debauching of the currency) and that could benefit from higher interest rates. Invest selectively in beaten down real estate and beaten down stocks (when you can find them), especially beaten down energy/commodity stocks. Settle for half a loaf in your job or business if you have to (which is why you need the cash stash). Hunker down... it's going to be a long night.

June 16, 2009 at 1:11 pm

Human1ty

I hate to say it, but aren't the corrupt banks the best bet at this point? Their balance sheets are horrible, but because of their governemt guarantees, it seems like they will have enough money to make new loans at higher rates. I can't see the current administration let much of a spread between the rates the banks pay and what consumers pay last forever, but at least in the short term, it is politically desirable for the banks to "earn" their way out of trouble.

June 16, 2009 at 1:03 pm

Robbie

I agree with you, and I pulled my money out of the market when it hit 14000. Now I am waiting for the interest rates to go up, maybe not as high as the Carter days but they will start increasing. This is a new game, one that no one understands nor can predict the out comes. Pull up your chair, get some popcorn --the show is far from over.

June 16, 2009 at 11:51 am

about this blog

  • Cody Willard is an anchor on the FOX Business Network. Willard is also the principal of an investment management company. He was a long-time featured columnist for the Financial Times and TheStreet.com as well as a regular featured economist and stock picker on CNBC's ''Kudlow & Company."